When someone dies owning property worth less than $75,000, families often assume they must navigate the full probate process with all its complexity and expense. Many people believe that any estate involving real property automatically requires formal probate administration regardless of the property’s value. This misconception can lead families to spend thousands of dollars on unnecessary legal proceedings when simpler alternatives exist.
Texas law provides streamlined procedures for small estates that allow families to transfer property without the time and cost of formal probate. However, these simplified procedures come with specific requirements and potential pitfalls that can create legal complications if not properly understood and executed.
Brackens v. Mayes, 2025 WL 2048201 (Tex. App.—Houston [14th Dist.] July 22, 2025), demonstrates how small estate affidavits can become entangled in property disputes and highlights the importance of understanding both the benefits and limitations of these simplified probate procedures. This case provides an opportunity to examine how small estate affidavits work in practice when they intersect with real estate transactions.
Facts & Procedural History
Mary and her husband Louis owned residential property in Houston that they had purchased during their marriage. When Louis died in January 2022, Mary wanted to sell the property and move to a smaller residence. The couple’s estate consisted solely of their home, which had a remaining mortgage balance of approximately $74,000.
Mary’s longtime friend Tammy offered to purchase the property. In September 2022, the parties signed a residential purchase contract under which Tammy would pay Mary $15,000 cash and assume the $74,000 mortgage balance. The total purchase price of $89,000 suggested the property’s value fell well within the range typically handled through small estate procedures rather than formal probate administration.
However, the transaction became complicated because Louis had died without completing any estate administration. Since the property was community property, Mary needed to establish her legal authority over Louis’s interest in the property before she could convey clear title to Tammy. The parties decided to use Texas’s small estate affidavit procedure to address this issue.
Tammy prepared and paid for filing a small estate affidavit to probate Louis’s estate. Mary signed the affidavit along with two witnesses who were Louis’s family members. The probate court approved the small estate affidavit on September 20, 2022, just four days after it was filed.
The transaction also involved Tammy preparing a general warranty deed that Mary signed on September 16, 2022—before the scheduled September 30 closing date and before the small estate affidavit was approved. Tammy recorded the deed in the Harris County property records on the same day Mary signed it despite not having paid the $15,000 purchase price or obtained lender approval to assume the mortgage.
The sale ultimately fell through when Mary requested additional time to move out and Tammy insisted on a lease arrangement that Mary refused to sign. Mary continued living in the property while Tammy filed an eviction action in November 2022. Mary then sued Tammy claiming violations of various fraud and property statutes, leading to the probate litigation that resulted in this court decision.
What Is a Small Estate Affidavit Under Texas Law?
Texas Estates Code Chapter 205 authorizes small estate affidavits as an alternative to formal probate administration when estates meet specific value and complexity requirements. These procedures allow families to transfer property ownership without the expense and delay of full probate proceedings, but they require careful compliance with statutory requirements.
Section 205.001 permits small estate affidavits when the value of the entire estate does not exceed $75,000, excluding homestead property and other exempt property. This means that the $75,000 limit applies only to non-exempt assets, while homestead property can pass through the small estate process regardless of its value. For many Texas families, this provision allows small estate procedures to handle estates that include valuable homestead property plus modest other assets.
The affidavit must be filed at least 30 days after the decedent’s death. The Estates Code imposes a four-year deadline for filing small estate affidavits. Section 205.002 requires the affidavit to include specific information about the decedent, the estate’s assets and liabilities, and the distributees entitled to receive the property. The affidavit must be sworn to by two disinterested witnesses who have personal knowledge of the facts stated in the affidavit.
Section 205.003 grants the court authority to approve small estate affidavits if the court finds that the requirements have been met and that the affidavit accurately describes the estate and its proper distributees. Once approved, the small estate affidavit serves as legal authority for transferring property ownership without the need for letters testamentary or letters of administration that would be required in formal probate proceedings.
Small estate affidavits have important limitations that restrict their use. They can only be used when the decedent died intestate or when a will exists but does not require probate (such as when the will only disposes of homestead property to the surviving spouse). The procedure cannot be used when formal probate administration is already pending or when disputes exist about the estate’s distribution.
How Do Small Estate Affidavits Work in Property Sales?
The Brackens case illustrates how small estate affidavits often arise in the context of property sales where the deceased person’s estate has not been administered. Mary and Louis owned their home as community property, which meant that Mary owned a one-half interest as her separate property while Louis’s one-half interest became part of his estate upon death.
Without estate administration, Mary could not convey clear title to the entire property because she lacked authority over Louis’s estate interest. This situation commonly arises when surviving spouses want to sell property before completing formal probate proceedings. The small estate affidavit procedure provides a streamlined method for resolving these ownership issues in appropriate cases.
In this case, Tammy took responsibility for preparing and filing the small estate affidavit, which raised unusual procedural questions. Typically, family members of the decedent handle estate administration matters rather than third-party purchasers. However, nothing in the Estates Code prohibits purchasers from initiating small estate procedures when it serves their legitimate business interests and when proper family members cooperate.
The timing of the various documents created potential legal complications. Tammy recorded the warranty deed on September 16, 2022, but the small estate affidavit was not approved until September 20, 2022. This four-day gap meant that when the deed was recorded, Mary had not yet established legal authority over Louis’s estate interest in the property.
The court’s approval of the small estate affidavit on September 20 gave legal effect to the estate administration and confirmed Mary’s authority over the property. However, the subsequent failure of the purchase transaction led to disputes about whether the warranty deed should remain effective and whether Tammy’s actions in recording the deed constituted fraud or other statutory violations. The court ultimately found insufficient evidence that Tammy acted fraudulently or with intent to harm Mary when she prepared and recorded the deed in connection with their planned property transaction.
What Practical Considerations Apply to Small Estate Affidavits?
Small estate affidavits offer significant advantages over formal probate administration for families with estates that meet the statutory requirements, but they require attention to procedural details and timing considerations. The most obvious benefit involves cost savings because small estate procedures typically cost hundreds rather than thousands of dollars. Formal probate administration can involve court filing fees, appraisal costs, publication expenses, and attorney fees that quickly exceed the value of modest estates.
Time savings provide another major advantage. Small estate affidavits can be prepared and approved within weeks, while formal probate administration typically takes several months even in uncomplicated cases. For families needing to transfer property ownership quickly—such as when facing foreclosure or urgent sale opportunities—small estate procedures can provide timely resolution.
However, small estate procedures have important limitations that make them inappropriate for many estates. The $75,000 limit on non-exempt property excludes many estates that include significant financial accounts, business interests, or valuable personal property. Estates with complex ownership structures, disputed claims, or complicated family situations often require the more comprehensive procedures available through formal administration.
Small estate affidavits provide limited protection against unknown creditors compared to formal probate administration. While formal probate includes notice procedures that can bar late-filed creditor claims, small estate procedures do not provide the same protection. This difference can leave distributees potentially liable for unknown estate debts that emerge after property has been transferred.
The requirement for two disinterested witnesses can create practical difficulties in some cases. The witnesses must have personal knowledge of the facts stated in the affidavit and cannot be interested in the estate. Finding appropriate witnesses who meet these requirements and are available to sign the affidavit can sometimes delay the process or require additional coordination among family members.
Texas probate courts exercise limited review authority over small estate affidavits compared to their comprehensive oversight role in formal administration proceedings. Courts typically approve small estate affidavits through documentary examination rather than extensive hearings when the statutory requirements appear to be met. This streamlined review process serves efficiency but places greater responsibility on the parties to ensure accuracy and legal compliance.
The Takeaway
Small estate affidavits provide valuable alternatives to formal probate administration for Texas families with estates that meet the statutory value and complexity requirements, but they demand careful attention to timing and procedural compliance. The Brackens case demonstrates that while small estate procedures can resolve property ownership issues effectively, they do not shield parties from separate legal disputes that may arise from the circumstances surrounding real estate transactions or estate administration decisions. Court approval of a small estate affidavit provides legal authority for property transfers but does not validate all aspects of related business dealings or protect against claims of fraud or breach of contract that may stem from how the parties conducted their affairs. Families considering small estate procedures should verify that their situations meet all statutory requirements while understanding that these simplified procedures offer less comprehensive legal protection than formal estate planning and probate administration would provide in complex or disputed cases.
Do you need help with a probate matter in San Antonio or the surrounding area? We are San Antonio probate attorneys. We help clients navigate the probate process. Call today for a free confidential consultation, (210) 239-8518.
Our San Antonio Probate Attorneys provide a full range of probate services to our clients, including helping with small estate affidavits. Affordable rates, fixed fees, and payment plans are available. We provide step-by-step instructions, guidance, checklists, and more for completing the probate process. We have years of combined experience we can use to support and guide you with probate and estate matters. Call us today for a FREE attorney consultation.
Disclaimer
The content of this website is for informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. The information presented may not apply to your situation and should not be acted upon without consulting a qualified probate attorney. We encourage you to seek the advice of a competent attorney with any legal questions you may have.
